Eight Positions Ranked Fourth in the AFC East, And The Dolphins Have No Answer For It

Alright, you guys, buckle up. We just got hit with some cold, hard truth from the AFC East and it ain't pretty for Miami. It's no shocker that the Dolphins aren't exactly penciled in for a deep playoff run in 2026, right? We've all seen the chatter about their massive roster overhaul and this being the first year of their rebuild. But listen, the real kicker, the absolute gut punch, isn't just a lack of talent, it's a massive, gaping hole of proven talent. We're talking Bill Parcells territory here, folks. He famously said, "potential means you haven't done anything yet." And based on these new rankings, Miami is swimming in potential and not much else that’s actually shown up on game day.

The Ugly Truth: Miami's Roster Takes a Massive Hit

So, here’s the scoop. The publishers and editors from the four On SI teams in the AFC East, like Ethan Hurwitz for the Patriots, Jovan Alford for the Jets, Ralph Ventre for the Bills, and Alain Poupart for the Dolphins, decided to rank every single team by position. They looked at 11 different spots: quarterback, running back, wide receiver, tight end, offensive line, interior defensive line, edge/outside linebacker, linebacker, cornerback, safety, and special teams including returners. And guess what? It was a bloodbath for Miami.

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

In the aggregate tally across all 11 positions, the Dolphins landed squarely in fourth place. By far. I mean, they were ranked fourth, dead last, in EIGHT of those 11 positions. And get this: for six of those spots, it was a unanimous decision. Not a single editor thought they were better than fourth at wide receiver, tight end, offensive line, edge/outside linebacker, cornerback, or safety. That’s a brutal, brutal read on their roster heading into the season, isn't it?

"Unproven" Isn't Just a Word, It's a Strategy (For Now)

But hey, let's circle back to that "unproven" issue, because that’s the heart of it all. At pretty much every single position, Miami is loaded with what you'd call "unknown commodities." We're talking young players, mostly draft picks, who are total wild cards. They could absolutely explode and become really good players as early as this season. Or, they could totally struggle, take their sweet time finding their rhythm, and just not break through yet. It’s a gamble, plain and simple.

Take wide receiver, for example. The Dolphins have three draft picks there: Caleb Douglas, Kevin Coleman Jr., and Chris Bell. And yeah, Bell's recovering from an ACL injury, but there's a chance one of those guys could turn into something special this year. Same goes for tight end, where they've got Greg Dulcich and rookie third-round pick Will Kacmarek. Look, the potential is there, no doubt. But for a team staring down a long rebuild, that potential better start showing up fast.

What does this mean for the Dolphins moving forward? Are these rankings a fair shake, or will these young guns defy expectations? We're about to find out when the season kicks off. Get ready, because it's going to be an interesting year watching if that potential can turn into actual results.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.