Joel Klatt Just Ranked CJ Carr No. 5, But the Reason Why Will Make Seahawks Fans Think TWICE

Alright, 12s, you KNOW we're always scouting, always looking ahead, even when our own boys are tearing it up on the field. Well, Joel Klatt just dropped his top-10 college QBs, and there's a name shaking up the 2027 draft conversation that needs to be on your radar: Notre Dame's CJ Carr. The dude's got serious buzz for a high pick, even national awards, and Klatt, one of the sharpest minds out there from Fox Sports, just pegged him at No. 5 nationwide!

Klatt's Top Tier, And Where Carr Stands

Seriously, Klatt puts Carr right there with some absolute monsters in college football: Oregon's Dante Moore, Texas' Arch Manning, Ohio State's Julian Sayin, and Ole Miss's Trinidad Chambliss are all ahead of him. That's some elite company right there at the top. Klatt himself called Carr "a really talented player," and honestly, after seeing him complete a rock-solid 66.6% of his passes last season, who can argue? The hype surrounding his second year as a starter is absolutely, 100% real.

The One Big Question Mark That Could Change EVERYTHING

But here's the kicker, the one detail Klatt dropped that should grab our attention, the kind of insight that separates the real analysts from the noise. He sees some factors that kinda put Carr lower, stuff the kid honestly can't even control. Get this: both of Notre Dame's first-round drafted running backs are GONE. Poof! Think about that for a second. Klatt's worried teams

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

will just stack the box against Carr now, basically forcing him to air it out way more often. Now, you might be thinking, "Hey, he completed 66.6% last year, that's legit, what's the big deal?" And yeah, that's a fair point! But it totally changes the calculus, right? It's a massive test of how much he can truly carry an offense, how much he can elevate those around him, especially without those elite ground threats making life easier. Klatt thinks it's a fair ranking, and I get it, especially since the guys above him also put up insane numbers last year. Many of these top QBs are gonna be early first-rounders, which could even tempt Carr to stay in college for another year, polish his game, and solidify that top spot. So, even though Carr landed at No. 5, Klatt basically said the guys from 2-5 are practically interchangeable, meaning this kid is still absolutely, unequivocally one of the top talents in college football. For us 12s, it's all about watching how this story plays out over the next season. Will those gone running backs expose a hidden weakness, or will Carr rise to the challenge, silence the doubters, and elevate his game even further? We're talking 2027 draft class, folks, and you know Mike Macdonald and Brian Fleury are ALWAYS thinking ahead, always looking for that next game-changer. You gotta keep an eye on Carr, because a quarterback with that kind of raw talent, and those kinds of high-stakes questions, is exactly the kind of saga that keeps us glued to the screen every single Saturday. Let's go, Hawks!

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.