Two Key Players Are Out, And College Basketball Has No Answer For Its New Eligibility Rule

Alright Seattle, buckle up! You know how college sports feels like it changes every other week? Well, this time, it's a real game-changer. The NCAA Division I Cabinet, in a move that feels absolutely massive, unanimously approved a five-year eligibility model on Tuesday. Yeah, you read that right: FIVE YEARS. It sounds like a total win, right? More time for players, more development, maybe even more loyalty. But hold up, because for some guys, this new rule actually means the exact opposite of a second chance.

The Immediate Heartbreak and the "Cheat Code"

Here’s the catch, and it’s a big one that's gonna sting a lot of players around the country. The new rules explicitly say that guys who already burned their final year of eligibility during the 2025-26 academic year are NOT getting that extra year. Talk about a gut punch, right?

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

For the WVU men's basketball team, this is huge for Treysen Eaglestaff and Brenen Lorient. They were the only two players who could have theoretically come back, but nope, this rule shuts the door on them. For now. You know how this works, though. We’ve seen it time and again: players in their spot, out of eligibility without a redshirt year, will likely try to get a temporary restraining order from a local judge to force the NCAA's hand. That's been the go-to "cheat code" for years, so why wouldn't it happen here too? It's wild to think about.

Reshaping Rosters and Unlocking Potential

But for everyone else on the roster, this is fantastic news! If you haven't redshirted, you're officially gaining an extra year of eligibility. If you did redshirt, your remaining years stay exactly the same. So, let’s talk about how this shakes up things for the Mountaineers:

• One year remaining: F Javan Buchanan, though he'll need a waiver for 2026-27.
• Two years remaining: G Finley Bizjack and G/F Seydou Traore.
• Three years remaining: G Joson Sanon and G Martin Somerville.
• Four years remaining: G MJ Feenane, G Amir Jenkins, F Evans Barning Jr., and C Mouhamed Sylla.
• Five years remaining: G Keonte Greybear, G Miles Sadler, F Max Olejasz, C Aliou Dioum, and C Amadou Seini.

This shift is going to massively impact how teams recruit and manage their rosters moving forward. Players might stick around longer, which could squeeze out some future high school prospects because, you know, roster limits are a thing. Then again, if a player is truly a superstar, they're probably not going to use all five years anyway, they'll be off to the NBA after year two or three.

The Future Is Now, And It's Complicated

This new rule is a huge boost for guys like Aliou Dioum and Amadou Seini. They're super talented but still a bit raw. Before, the team might have had to consider redshirting them to save a year. Now, they can play in games during the 2026-27 season, get that crucial experience, and develop without burning through their eligibility. It's a game-changer for player development.

The biggest questions now? How many players will West Virginia sign in the 2027 recruiting class, knowing some of their current guys might be sticking around longer? And which players will truly capitalize on that extra year? The college hoops landscape got a whole lot more complex and exciting, folks. Stay tuned, because this story is just getting started!

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.