Herb Dean Is Bleeding MMA's Integrity Dry, And The Sport Has No Answer

Alright, Emerald City fight fans, let's talk about something that's got my blood absolutely boiling after UFC Baku: the officiating. Seriously, it feels like every single week we're throwing our arms up in frustration at the refs and judges. Questionable calls, bogus scorecards, or even worse, flat-out breaking the Unified Rules. This past weekend on June 27, it was especially bad, with not one, but two insane moments that left everyone scratching their heads.

Jim Perdios Kicked Off UFC Baku With A Botched Stop

The prelims started with Tahir Abdullayev and Jefferson Nascimento. Both guys were making their UFC debuts, big talents from the regional scene, but what a way to begin the night. Referee Jim Perdios stepped in and turned what was already a pretty boring fight, with zero offense between them, into a full-blown groan-fest. Nascimento got a warning for lack of activity, which is fine, but Abdullayev got NO warning, even though UFC Stats says Nascimento outworked him in the first two rounds. Hold up, what? Then, Abdullayev landed a punch on Nascimento after the second-round horn. And guess what? No point deduction. Nada. This whole thing was like a terrible flashback to the Holly Holm vs. Germaine de Randamie debacle. But the absolute cherry on top? Abdullayev dropped Nascimento, rained down shots, and Nascimento grabbed him from the bottom. We've seen fighters in way worse spots. But Perdios just stepped in and stopped it! Nascimento was immediately on his feet protesting, and even the UFC's own commentary team couldn't defend the stoppage. You can't start a card like that.

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

Herb Dean's Co-Main Event Failures Proved Everyone Right

Okay, if starting with a controversial fight is bad, having your co-main event feature more ref drama is a nightmare. And guess who was the referee for Shara “Bullet” Magomedov vs. Michel Pereira? Only Herb Dean, the guy whose "best days are far behind him," and whose name is "near-frequent" for controversial officiating these days. Alex Pereira is already targeting him for "terrible officiating" in his UFC Freedom 250 fight against Ciryl Gane. So, how'd it start? Pereira dropped Magomedov in the first round. While Pereira was on top, Magomedov pulled his hair, on multiple occasions. No disqualification, no TKO, no point deduction. Just a "hard warning." You'd think a hard warning means a point deduction next, right? Nope. Third round, Magomedov lands an eye poke on Pereira. Dean does nothing. Not even a point deduction! That's huge, because Magomedov won on the scorecards. If Dean had just done his job, it would have been a draw at best for Magomedov, if not a straight-up win for Pereira. Andrew Richardson from MMA Mania is right, these officiating issues are way too common.

So, here we are again. Another UFC card, another officiating disaster. Every time there's an outcry for more scrutiny and watch-dogging of officials, "nothing ever happens." We get it, these refs and judges fall under state athletic commissions with government oversight. But seriously, how much more is it going to take before somebody steps in and shakes things up for these people who hold so much power in our sport? Education and outcry can only do so much. We need consequences. But honestly, I'm not holding my breath, and that's the frustrating part.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.