Jonathan Taylor Is a Trade Candidate and Nobody in Indy Is Ready For It

Alright, 12s, did you just see the absolute noise coming out of Indianapolis? We're barely into the regular season and an NFL insider is already dropping bombs: Jonathan Taylor, *Jonathan Taylor*, is being called a trade candidate. Let that sink in. A franchise running back, arguably one of the most dynamic players in the league, in June? Man, you gotta wonder what's going on behind closed doors with the Colts. This isn't some quiet rumor, folks, this is an analyst straight up putting it out there, and the entire league just felt the ripple.

Indy's Roster Looks Like a Mosh Pit

Seriously, while we're over here in the Emerald City getting ready for what's next, Indianapolis is looking like a full-blown roster scramble. We’re talking about wide receiver battles all over the place. Can Ashton Dulin lock down a starting spot? What kind of role can Laquon Treadwell carve out, or Nick Westbrook-Ikhine after his new deal? They're even asking what EJ Horton and undrafted Raylen Sharpe can bring to the WR room. Plus, their backup QB situation with Riley Leonard is under the microscope, with Coach Steichen evaluating his offseason. And let's not even start on special teams, where they're weighing who’s a lock and who’s on the bubble. There's even talk about a recent draft pick's roster spot being in jeopardy. It’s chaos! You'd think

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

early in the season, things would be a little more settled.

Big Names, Big Questions for the Colts

And it's not just the bottom of the roster. An NFL insider also identified a potential "surprise" starter on defense for Indy. Plus, while all this trade talk swirls around Jonathan Taylor, there's also an update about his contract extension. Talk about mixed signals, right? They've got three players ranked among the most "important" in the NFL for 2026, which is huge, but it still makes you scratch your head about the Taylor situation. On the bright side, there are "2 promising developments" for their secondary, which is something. And second-year tight end Tyler Warren has revealed his expectations, which is a good sign for individual player development. But man, the free agent edge rusher market for them is shrinking, which doesn't sound great for shoring up the defense. Look, this is all happening in Indianapolis, but you can bet the rest of the league, and especially us in Seattle, are watching every single twitch. A talent like Jonathan Taylor hitting the trade market would send shockwaves everywhere. It's early in the season, and teams are still figuring things out, but the Colts have some massive questions swirling around their most important player. What happens next with Taylor could totally shift the landscape of the AFC, and you know we're keeping our eyes peeled to see how it all shakes out.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.