The All-Star Outfield Vote is a Total TRAINWRECK and Fans Deserve Better
Alright, Seattle, listen up! We're only a few weeks into the All-Star voting, and folks, it's already getting WILD. Early results dropped Monday, and if you thought fans were just gonna pick the best players, think again. This is a popularity contest, plain and simple, and right now, some of the results are straight-up baffling. We're talking about deserving guys getting snubbed hard while some names you wouldn't expect are leading the pack. It's time to talk about what's going down, especially with that National League outfield ballot, because it's a mess.
NL Ballots Are Brewing Chaos
Let's dive into the National League first, because there are some head-scratchers brewing. At catcher, Atlanta's Drake Baldwin is crushing it, leading Will Smith of the Dodgers by a whopping 310,000 votes. And honestly? Baldwin deserves it. The dude is slashing .303/.389/.543 with 13 homers in just 48 games. He's been the best, period. First base is looking good too, with Freddie Freeman ahead of Matt Olson. Both are tearing it up, so no complaints there. Second base, though? Ozzie Albies leads Bryson Stott, but the numbers say guys like Brice Turang and rookie JJ Wetherholt have been even better. The margins are tight, but still. CJ Abrams is leading at shortstop and he's been fantastic, but Mookie Betts, who's been struggling and hurt, is right behind him by only 12,000 votes. Max Muncy at third? He's absolutely killing it at the ballot box and on the field, 100% the best. And for DH, Shohei Ohtani has a massive 300,000-vote lead over Kyle Schwarber, which feels about right. They're the top two, no doubt.
Trade on Every Game with Kalshi
Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.
But here's the kicker, the real gut punch for anyone who watches the games: the National League outfield. Andy Páges, Ronald Acuña, and Brandon Marsh are currently running 1-2-3. Meanwhile, the actual best performers by Fangraphs WAR, guys like Pete Crow-Armstrong, James Wood, and Corbin Carroll, are nowhere near the top. None of them are even higher than seventh in the voting! Wood is the closest, but still trailing third place by 230,000 votes. This isn't just a slight mismatch; this is an outright fan nightmare, and it's making a mockery of who actually deserves to be there. We expect some wildness, but this is a bridge too far, and we've got until June 25 to fix it.
AL Voting: Some Right, Some Seriously Wrong
Over in the American League, things are a mix of righteous picks and some real head-scratchers too. Shea Langeliers of the A's is steamrolling the catcher vote, more than 400,000 ahead of the next guy, and he totally deserves it. He's been the best catcher in the AL. Dillon Dingler of the Tigers is also having a great first half and should make the finals. At first base, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. leads Ben Rice despite a "disappointing first half." Rice, along with Nick Kurtz, are way more deserving, but Kurtz is 330,000 votes behind Vlad. What gives? Blue Jays fans are voting like Braves fans, stuffing the ballot box without mercy!
Second base has Ernie Clement of the Blue Jays leading Ezequiel Duran by over 600,000 votes. At least this pair makes sense for the finals. Bobby Witt Jr. is absolutely running away with the shortstop vote, and deservedly so. We just need rookie Kevin McGonigle to overcome Andrés Giménez to get the right duo in the finals. Junior Caminero and Japanese import Kazuma Okamoto are 1-2 at third, but Miguel Vargas of the White Sox is out there deserving a spot. Sox fans need to channel their inner Mayor Daley and start stuffing those ballot boxes to overcome a 230,000-vote deficit. Yordan Alvarez is the clear leader at DH, with Yandy Díaz breathing down George Springer's neck to create a righteous final. And for the outfield, we've got injured Aaron Judge and rejuvenated Mike Trout leading the charge, which is hard to argue with. Cody Bellinger is ahead of Byron Buxton by 36,000 votes, and while Bellinger isn't undeserving, Buxton has definitely earned a spot too.
Look, fan voting is what it is, but when you see such a disconnect between performance and popularity, it just stings. The next phase of voting is crucial, especially for those National League outfielders who are actually putting in the work. Let's hope for some justice! Speaking of putting in work, our Emerald City squad just picked up a big win! The Mariners took down the Baltimore Orioles last night, a solid 3-1 victory at T-Mobile Park. We need to keep that energy up, both on the field and in making sure our All-Star picks are legit. Keep those votes coming, but let's make 'em count for the right guys!
This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.