Two Max Muncys Started at 3B and Batting 7th, and Nobody in MLB Was Ready For It
Baseball fans, what went down Monday night was WILD. Max Muncy played third base AND batted seventh for the Athletics. Across the diamond? Max Muncy played third base AND batted seventh for the Dodgers. No, your eyes aren't messing with you. It’s Maximum Muncy, and it's officially baseball history!
History Made: Two Muncys, Same Spot
How often does something this specific happen? This Monday, in the series opener at Sutter Health Park, was only the third time since 1901 that two players with the same name squared off, same position, and same lineup spot. The only other time was in June 2000, when Alex Gonzalez and Álex González both hit seventh and started at shortstop for the Blue Jays and Marlins. What makes this Muncy matchup crazier? Both Max Muncys share the same August 25th birthday, born exactly 12 years apart, and totally unrelated! The baseball gods have a twisted sense of humor, don't they?
Trade on Every Game with Kalshi
Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.
From Childhood Dream to Double Muncy Reality
For the A's Max Muncy, this wasn't some random game. He'd been waiting since he was a kid! He learned about the elder Muncy, drafted by the A's in 2012, through his grandparents when he was eight. The younger Muncy followed his namesake's journey to the pros. He said on A’s Cast: "When he was in college at Baylor, my grandparents found him and they’re like, ‘Oh, there’s another baseball player,’ I knew when he got drafted. I knew when he was with the A’s. I knew when they let him go and the Dodgers picked him up. All the transactions, I had known because every time I went over to my grandparents’ house they would keep me updated.”
It almost happened last season! After making the A's Opening Day roster in 2025, the A's Muncy thought he'd face the Dodgers' Muncy in May at Dodger Stadium. But, the A's Muncy landed on the injured list. Cruel twist of fate!
Their first Major League game together? Yes, but not their first professional encounter. That was in August 2024. A's Muncy (Triple-A Las Vegas) faced a rehabbing Dodgers Muncy (Triple-A Oklahoma City). The A's Muncy shined brighter, with four hits including two doubles! They even took a picture before, and ran into each other at a restaurant after. The younger Muncy said the elder "kind of did more of the talking," adding, "I was like, ‘Nice to meet you. Glad we finally did this.’ He just kind of was like, ‘Hey man, you’ve had a great start to your career. You’re doing good stuff. I wish you the best.’ It was kind of just mutual. … We’re somehow attached in some way. It feels like there’s an attachment. This was before I debuted. He was like, ‘Man, I hope you make it up. Good luck.’" What a moment!
Baseball can throw some curveballs, but this was pure knuckleball destiny. While our Mariners weren't involved, these crazy moments remind you why we bleed green and blue for this game. You never know what wild story will unfold next. Keep those eyes peeled, folks, because every game is a chance for something truly unforgettable!
This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.