Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Is Batting .277 With a D+ Grade, And League Fans Are Still Voting Him An All-Star

Okay, Seattle, we need to talk about what's going on in the AL, because this is wild. Vladimir Guerrero Jr., a guy who's been an All-Star starter four of the last five years, just got slapped with a D+ grade for his first-half performance. A D-PLUS! Meanwhile, he's somehow still racking up votes to be an All-Star starter, pulling in almost two and a half million of 'em! What does this even mean for a player who's supposed to be a cornerstone, a superstar? Honestly, it feels like the national fans are living in a different universe, especially when you compare his numbers to guys who are *actually* raking.

The Numbers Don't Lie, So Why Are We Voting Like They Do?

Look, I bleed green and blue, and I watch every single game. So when I see a stat comparison like this, it makes my head spin. Take Nick Kurtz, the first baseman from Oakland, and put him next to Vladdy. It's not even a contest based on performance, yet guess who's headed for All-Star Phase 2? Kurtz is rocking a 3.7 WAR, 19 home runs, a .540 slugging percentage, and a whopping 163 OPS+. Dude even collected 20 RBI and a .385 OBP in June, something only one other batter did! Vladdy? He's sitting at a 0.8 WAR, just 4 home runs, a .363 slugging, and a sad 98 OPS+. Yet, the fans went hard for Guerrero, giving him 2,459,950 votes compared to Kurtz's 948,434 votes. It's baffling, honestly. Are we voting on reputation or production anymore? It makes you wonder what attitude national fans have versus what regional die-hards actually see on the field.

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

That $500 Million Question Mark Hanging Over Toronto

And then there's the money. Oh, the money! We're talking about one of MLB's highest-paid players, who's scheduled to make $35.7 million this season. He's locked into a massive $14-year, $500 million deal that keeps him off the free-agent market until 2040. For that kind of investment, you expect consistent, game-changing production every single night. And don't get me wrong, we know Vladdy can do it. Over the last five years, he's averaged more than 30 home runs and nearly 100 RBI. That's been his *floor* offensively. But this season, it's a completely different story. He opened the year slashing .277/.360/.363, with only 32 RBI and six stolen bases. The failing grade isn't just about those overall numbers, it's about the frustrating inconsistency. He's only managed back-to-back RBI outings five times this season, with just two of those happening before June 10. That's just not the lineup presence you expect from a player with his talent and paycheck.

Can He Turn the Bat Around?

Now, I saw that flicker of hope on Friday. He went 2-for-4 with two RBI and a run scored in their 5-4 loss to the Texas Rangers. A small step, but a step. He was scheduled to bat second against Rangers starter Cal Quantrill on Saturday. The real question for Toronto, and for Vladdy's long-term legacy, is whether he can begin to stack that production. Can he find that rhythm, that consistency, that power he's known for? Because Kurtz is out here balling on a one-year, $785,000 deal, delivering massive value. Comparing their value, it's still unfair, but not in the way you'd think for a $500 million superstar. For the Blue Jays, and for Guerrero himself, the pressure is absolutely on to start performing like the player we all know he can be.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.