Five Bats Ready to Explode Tonight: May 5 Home Run Picks and Odds

May 5 brings a full MLB slate with all 15 teams in action, and the early season home run leaderboard is loaded with surprises. We're still in the opening stretch, nowhere near the All-Star break, but plenty of teams are already setting their tone for what's to come. Here are the five best bets for a long ball tonight.

5. Ketel Marte (+380)

The Arizona Diamondbacks star has cooled off lately. Marte sits at five home runs with a .214 batting average over the last month, but tonight's matchup against the Pittsburgh Pirates gives him a strong chance to go yard.

4. Juan Soto (+344)

Things have been rough in Queens. The New York Mets are struggling hard, despite spending big in the offseason, and if they keep this up they're going to miss the playoffs entirely. But Juan Soto has been the bright spot in all that chaos. He's got three home runs and a solid .301 batting average to show he's still one of the most dangerous hitters in the league.

3. Max Muncy (+334)

The Los Angeles Dodgers slugger has crushed nine home runs already this season. Muncy's off to a solid start, and the odds at +334 say he's got a real shot at another one tonight. He's also creeping closer to a 30-home run season.

2. Matt Olson (+333)

Matt Olson has been absolutely incredible for the Atlanta Braves. He's already got a dozen home runs in 2026, sitting with a .300 batting average, and he's a huge favorite to go deep tonight when the Braves face the Seattle Mariners.

1. Mike Trout (+281)

Mike Trout is one of the most dangerous hitters in all of baseball. The Angels superstar is in elite form right now, slashing .250 with 10 home runs on the season. Tonight the Angels face the Chicago White Sox, and Trout tops the list of guys most likely to take one yard.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.