Worst Home Run Derby Performances Of All Time

Worst Home Run Derby Performances Of All Time


Seattle On Tap Edit/ Britannica 

The HR Derby features some of the best power hitters in baseball. But you aren't guaranteed fireworks every time. These are the worst HR Derby Performances Of All Time.

25. Chipper Jones (1998) 1 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

The future hall of famer had a bad track record in HR derbies. And the 1998 HR derby was his worst with just one home run at Coors Field out of all places. 

24. Matt Kemp (2012) 1 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Kemp was the captain for the NL in 2012. He followed his 2011 HR derby performance where he hit 2 home runs with a total of 1 HR in Kansas City in 2012.

23. Sammy Sosa (1999) 1 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Drafted 10th overall in 2011. Gabbert signed a deal worth $12 million and went 5-22 as a starter.

22. Bo Jackson (1998) 1 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Well Bo Jackson had a great all star game that season. He won the MVP of the game. But in the HR derby? Well he managed just one HR. 

21. Mark McGwire (1987)


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

McGwire had some great HR derbies. But this was not one of them. He was a rookie and managed to hit just 1 HR in this derby.

20. Cal Ripken Jr. (1985) - 1 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

This was the very first HR derby and it was kind of a low key event. He managed to hit just 1 HR in Minnesota.

19. Gary Gaetti (1989) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

He was a two-time Silver Slugger at third base. But the 1989 HR derby was not his best work. He managed 0 HRs in Anaheim.

18. Howard Johnson (1991) - 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Johnson was a two time NL HR champion in his career. But in the 1991 HR Derby he struggled big time and hit 0 HRs.

17. Chris Sabo (1991) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Known as spuds he was a popular Reds third baseman. At the 1991 HR Derby in Toronto he managed to hit 0 HRs.

16. Greg Vaughn (1996) 0 HR


The Sports On Tap Edit

Vaughn had 31 HRs in the 1996 season. But in Philadelphia at "The Vet" he managed to hit 0 HRs at the HR Derby.

15. Jason Bay (2005) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap/ Bio

At Detroit's Comerica Park there was plenty of HRs in the Derby. But Jason Bay had a total of ZERO of them.

14. Brandon Inge (2009) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ Richy

Inge was a late blooming slugger. He went into the HR derby in St. Louis and gave the crowd a dud with 0 HRs.

13. Bret Boone (2003) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Boone came in to Chicago's US Cellular Field ready to hit some dingers. Well, he hit zero.

12. Nomar Garciaparra (1997) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Nomar wasn't known 100% for his power anyways. But he managed to hit 0 HRs in Cleveland's Jacobs Field which was just terrible. 

11. Gary Sheffield (1996) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Sheffield finished his career with 509 HRs. But at the derby in 1996? He managed to not get one out of the yard.

10. Bobby Bonilla (1990) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

10 outs to get one out of the yard. But nope, Bonilla couldn't get any out.

9. Darryl Strawberry (1990) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

The 1990 derby was tough. And Strawberry was one of those who struggled and ended up with 0 HRs at Wrigley Field.

8. Jose Canseco (1990) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

He was already a former MVP (1988) and was known for his crazy power. But the cursed 1990 HR derby got him too with 0 HR.

7. Cecil Fielder (1990) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Uh oh. Another victim of the 1990 HR derby. Fielder was another player who had 0 HRs in the 1990 derby in Chicago.

6. Mike Piazza (1993)


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

One of the greatest (if not greatest) power hitting catchers of all time. But at Camden Yards in 1993 he had 0 HRs.

5. Jim Thomas (1997) 0 HR


The Sports On Tap Edit

He was expected to do big things with the Derby being in Cleveland. Instead, he put up a dud with 0 HRs.

4. Ken Griffey Jr. (1990) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

Junior was amazing in HR derbies. He won it three different times. But the 1990 derby was not his best work. Another one of the five players who failed to hit a HR in the derby at Wrigley Field.

3. Troy Glaus (2001) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

He came in as the reigning HR champion of the AL. But at Safeco Field he was not able to put up any HRs.


2. Yasiel Puig (2014) 0 HR


Seattle On Tap Edit/ MLB.com

One of the most electric stars at the time he came in ready to put on a show. Instead, he had 0 HRs.

1. Robinson Cano (2012) 0 HR


The Sports On Tap Edit

He was the defending derby champion and the AL team captain. Well at Kansas City's Kauffman Stadium he put no HRs.

Back to blog

Leave a comment