202 Catches vs. 133: The $92 Million Blunder That Has Green Bay Fans Sweating

Yo, fam! We gotta talk about something wild in Green Bay. Sports Illustrated's Matt Verderame just dropped a truth bomb on the Packers' roster moves. Their decision to let Romeo Doubs walk while dropping a massive extension on Christian Watson? Verderame thinks it could be a HUGE mistake, and when you look at the numbers, it's tough to argue.

Are the Packers Built for a Ring?

The Packers have been doing okay, right? Three straight playoff berths, but that "crushing" wild-card loss to the Bears stung. Verderame, in his Super Bowl LXI road map, gives props to Coach Matt LaFleur and QB Jordan Love. But he’s asking the big question: "is there enough around them to not only get back to the postseason but make a real run at a Super Bowl appearance for the first time since the 2010 season?" GM Brian Gutekunst has good players, but "good" doesn't win a Lombardi. You need "great," and Verderame eyes one decision that might keep them from being great.

Watson In, Doubs Out: The Contract Crunch

So, what’s the big deal? Wide receivers. The Packers chose Watson over Doubs. Doubs, the more reliable guy, signed a four-year, $68 million contract with the Patriots, including $35 million guaranteed for 2026 and 2027. Watson, tagged as the more explosive player, got a four-year extension worth $92 million from the Packers. It includes $31 million guaranteed, but with a $13 million roster bonus in 2028, it’s really a tw

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

o-year deal before reassessment. Verderame suggested Gutekunst could've traded Watson for a mid-round pick, then signed Doubs for the *exact same figures* New England paid. An extra draft pick AND the more reliable player? Oof.

The Stat Sheet Speaks Volumes

This isn't just a gut feeling. The stats back it up. * Christian Watson (2022 second-round pick): Played 48 games, caught 133 passes for 2,264 yards, 20 touchdowns. Catch rate: 58.6 percent. Success rate: 52.4 percent. * Romeo Doubs (2022 fourth-round pick): Played 59 games, caught 202 passes for 2,424 yards, 21 touchdowns. Catch rate: 64.1 percent. Success rate: 54.1 percent. Verderame asked, “What argument is there for Watson being a better player? It’s tough to make it.” Doubs played more games, caught more passes, and has similar yardage with more TDs. "Reliable" for a Super Bowl run sounds pretty good. So, where does this leave the Packers? They made their bed. This decision, dropping $92 million on one receiver while letting a statistically more reliable one walk, is a huge bet on "potential." Verderame's take is damning, putting a massive spotlight on Watson's performance. Can he prove all the doubters wrong? Can he elevate the Packers beyond "good" to "great" and deliver on that Super Bowl dream? Right now, that's a tough sell. And even though Verderame finds it tough to argue for Watson, apparently, there *are* easy arguments. We just haven't heard 'em yet. We'll be watching how this plays out.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.