Nolan Arenado Got a Standing O, But the Diamondbacks Are Already 39-39 and Falling Apart

Holy moly, can you believe what's happening in St. Louis right now? Nolan Arenado, the guy who used to call Busch Stadium home, is back. And yeah, he got the standing ovation he deserved, the whole nine yards, pure class from the Cardinals faithful. But don't let that emotional reunion distract you from the real story here, because the Arizona Diamondbacks are in a full-blown tailspin, and it's getting ugly fast. After dropping Monday's opener 3-2, they're sitting at a dismal .500 mark with a 39-39 record, looking nothing like a team ready to make some noise.

The Homecoming That Couldn't Hide the Mess

So, yeah, Nolan Arenado's return was definitely the feel-good moment of the series. The dude played for the Cardinals from 2021-25, racking up three All-Star nods and two Gold Gloves. He even told reporters he genuinely thought he'd finish his career there when he opted-in back in 2022. "Baseball happens and things happen," he said, and boy, did they ever. St. Louis shook things up after missing the postseason for three straight years, shipping Arenado off to the D-backs in January for right-handed pitcher Jack Fernandez. But no hard feelings, right? Arenado made it clear, "St. Louis is always first class. They know how much I care about them and how much I loved my time here." The fans absolutely ate it up, giving him a huge standing ovation before his first at-bat on Monday.

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

But here's the kicker: those good vibes end with Arenado's personal story. His team? They've been bleeding out. Dropping three straight games has sunk them to 8-15 in their last 23 contests, shoving them right back to that painful .500 mark. That's not a slump, people, that's a trend that needs to turn around ASAP.

Can Eduardo Rodriguez Save This Shipwreck?

Alright, so it's Tuesday night, and the D-backs are desperate to stop the bleeding. They're sending left-hander Eduardo Rodriguez to the mound, and if anyone can get them back on track, it's probably him. The guy has been an absolute force this season, rocking a 6-2 record with a sparkling 2.45 ERA. He's been lights out, allowing one or zero runs in eight of his 15 starts. His last outing? Seven innings of one-run ball in an 8-1 win against the Angels. That's the kind of performance they need! But here's the wrinkle: he's only faced the Cardinals twice in his 250 career starts, going 1-0 with a 5.56 ERA against them. Not exactly a dominant sample size, is it?

He'll be facing Cardinals right-hander Kyle Leahy, who's looking to rebound himself after taking a loss against San Diego last Wednesday. Leahy (5-4, 4.63 ERA) struck out seven but gave up three runs and seven hits over six innings in that 6-1 setback. This will be his first career start against the Diamondbacks, though he's logged 3 1/3 relief innings against them with an 8.10 ERA.

Nathan Church Is Making Noise

While the D-backs are trying to figure things out, the Cardinals have a young dude making waves. Center fielder Nathan Church, just 25, was a total catalyst in Monday's win, racking up two hits, an RBI, and a stolen base from the bottom of the order. This kid has been on fire, hitting .299 over the last 30 games and stepping up big time to replace Opening Day starter Victor Scott II. Cardinals manager Oliver Marmol isn't holding back the praise, calling Church "hungry" and saying he "wants to be really good." He's seeing more pitches, drawing walks, and Marmol pointed out his speed, ability to "take a bag," and "really, really good defender" skills. That's high praise, and it shows on the field.

So, Tuesday night is a huge one for the D-backs. Can Rodriguez put a stop to this freefall, or will the Cardinals keep riding the momentum of Church and Arenado's mixed emotions? We're on the edge of our seats, hoping for some serious baseball to unfold!

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.