One Pollster Said Jack Campbell Was The Best In Football. So Why Is He Still Ranked Fifth?

One Pollster Said Jack Campbell Was The Best In Football. So Why Is He Still Ranked Fifth? Jack Campbell just bulldozed his way onto ESPN's top-10 linebacker list for the first time in his three-year career, but can we talk about this ranking for a second? The dude is only fifth! Fifth, after a first-team All-Pro season where he absolutely went off. What are these NFL executives, coaches, and scouts really watching?

The Head-Scratching Numbers Game for Campbell

Okay, so Campbell landed at number five. That puts him behind Fred Warner, Roquan Smith, Carson Schwesinger, and Zack Baun. Look, no shade to those guys, especially when three of them are All-Pros themselves. Warner and Smith have multiple All-Pro nods, so yeah, they're legit. But seeing Schwesinger, who's only had one professional season, jump ahead of Campbell is a head-scratcher, even if Schwesinger had a tremendous rookie year. What's even wilder is the huge split in opinion on Campbell. We're talking extremes here. The survey had at least one pollster calling him the *best* linebacker in football, making him one of only three top-10 LBs to even get a first-place vote. Think about that! The *best*! But then, some other ballot had him completely outside the top 10. How do you go from number one to nowhere on the same list? Earlier this offseason, his own peers ranked him as the 88th best player in the entire league, which gives you a sense of the respect he's earned on the field.

Campbell's Insane Production Speaks Volumes

Let's just be real, Campbell is coming off his best professional season, period. It's not even a debate. He earned those first-team All-Pro honors, no question. The stats back it up: he finished second among all linebackers in PFF grade with an insane 90.2. He blew past his previous career highs, racking up 176 tackles, 5.0 sacks, three forced fumbles, two fumble recoveries, and nine tackles for loss. That's straight-up dominance from the middle of the field. What do you do when a player performs like that? You pay the man! And the team did just that, handing him a fat four-year, $81 million extension, locking him in as one of the highest-paid linebackers in the game. You don't drop that kind of cash if you don't believe in the guy. An AFC assistant coach nailed it, calling him an "Excellent football IQ, tough, physical, plays downhill, instinctive, aware, leader , throwback football player." That's the kind of praise you love to hear. This season, Campbell is going to carry even more weight. Alex Anzalone is gone from that linebacker room, and there are still a lot of questions and moving pieces in the secondary. The pressure is on, and Campbell will absolutely have to take his game to another level. If he does, watch him climb this list even higher in 2027. He's already the sixth player from the squad to land in the top 10 at their position, joining Jahmyr Gibbs (RB), Aidan Hutchinson (Edge), Sam LaPorta (TE), Penei Sewell (OT), and Jared Goff (QB). This team is loaded, and Campbell is right there in the thick of it, ready to prove he's not just top five, but the absolute best.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.

Back to blog

Leave a comment