Sean Payton Called for Rutgers Special and His Broncos Punt Team Just Said 'Nah'

Sean Payton Called for Rutgers Special and His Broncos Punt Team Just Said 'Nah' Alright, Seattle, you gotta hear about this wild play call that almost, *almost*, went down in a Broncos playoff overtime win against the Bills! Their coach, Sean Payton, confirmed after the game he called a fake punt on fourth-and-11 during overtime, but get this, his players completely changed it at the line of scrimmage and ran a normal punt instead. Seriously, can you believe that?

The Audacious Call That Never Was

This went down at the end of the first possession of overtime. Broncos had the ball on their own 38-yard line, fourth-and-11. Payton told his punt team to run the fake, a massive risk on his part. Think about it: if the fake failed, the Bills would've taken over in position for a long field goal, needing just one to win the whole thing. Payton's known for taking big gambles on special teams, but this one was next level, even for him.

Rutgers Special: Payton's Secret Weapon

An ESPN article dove deep into Payton's prep for this kinda moment. The dude apparently spent hours studying fake punts, eventually finding one he loved that the Raiders once pulled off. The Broncos even adopted it into their special teams playbook and gave it a killer name: "Rutgers Special." The plan for this play was for the ball to go directly to the upback, Michael Burton, who, you guessed it, played at Rutgers. But even with all that prep, even with the call made right there in overtime, the Broncos never actually ran Rutgers Special in that divisional playoff game. His players just… didn't. What a wild turn of events. That playoff overtime win could've gone so differently. Man, what a gamble Payton was ready to take. You just gotta wonder what was going through those players' heads!

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.

Back to blog

Leave a comment