Arch Manning's Upside Isn't Enough: The SEC QB Draft Just Delivered a Truth Bomb

Alright, football fanatics, hold onto your hats because the talk of the offseason isn't about the Seahawks' new plays for Sam Darnold, but some wild action brewing down south! We're talking about a head-to-head, no-holds-barred SEC quarterback draft put together by USA TODAY, and lemme tell you, it went off the rails faster than a two-point conversion gone wrong. Blake Toppmeyer and John Adams went at it, picking their top four QBs, and some of these choices are absolutely shocking. If you thought you knew who was going first, you might wanna sit down for this.

The Top Gunslinger Showdown: Proven vs. Potential

Adams, with the very first pick, went straight for a proven winner: Trinidad Chambliss from Mississippi. And honestly, can you blame him? Adams calls it a "no-brainer," and if you saw the Sugar Bowl replay, you know why. The guy runs, he passes, he leads, he wins. He's the full package, no question. But then Toppmeyer stepped up with his first pick, and things got spicy. He snatched up Arch Manning from Texas! Yeah, the name carries weight, and Toppmeyer is banking on that "tremendous upside." He needs Manning to play like he did in the Citrus Bowl against Michigan, hoping that in his second full year as a starter, he'll finally find that consistency after a mountain of pressure last season. Toppmeyer didn't stop there. For his second pick, he grabbed Gunner Stockton from Georgia. This guy's a certified gamer, a winner with a cannon arm who can also scoot for some serious yardage. Toppmeyer highlighted how Stockton elevates his play in huge matchups, pointing to his elite performances last season against Tennessee, Ole Miss, and Texas. That's a clutch factor you just can't teach, and it’s why he’s a massive pick.

Bold Moves and Future Bets: Risky Business or Genius?<

Trade on Every Game with Kalshi

Click Here to sign up to Kalshi — Free $10 when you sign up using our link or use code: ONTAPSEA. The only federally regulated prediction market in the US. Trade on real sports outcomes. Available in all 50 states.

/h2> Adams made a bold play for his second pick, taking Sam Leavitt from LSU. This one's a bit of a gamble, counting on Leavitt getting healthy after a foot injury and returning to his 2024 form. If he does, especially under Lane Kiffin and Charlie Weis Jr., this pick could be a steal. Then, Adams continued his roster build with Byrum Brown from Auburn. New coach Alex Golesh smartly brought Brown with him from South Florida, and the kid has shown he can hit downfield strikes and even lower his shoulder to move the chains on third-and-3. You gotta love a QB willing to put his body on the line! Toppmeyer rounded out his lineup by snagging Marcel Reed from Texas A&M, a guy who battled inconsistency last season and didn't finish strong. But when he was good, he was *really* good. If Reed can cut down on those interceptions, he's got the skills to be among the SEC's elite. For his final pick, Toppmeyer went with John Mateer from Oklahoma, hoping for the player from last September before he broke his hand. Mateer showed grit returning after just one missed game, but the post-injury performance wasn't the same. Toppmeyer wants that early-season form. Adams, pulling out all the stops for his last pick, twisted the knife with pure potential: Keelon Russell from Alabama. He's never started a game, barely played as a true freshman, but he's a former five-star recruit with dual-threat capabilities and rave reviews from the spring. It’s a huge bet, but sometimes those big swings pay off in a massive way. So, who built the better roster here? Adams finished with Trinidad Chambliss, Sam Leavitt, Byrum Brown, and Keelon Russell. Toppmeyer’s crew is Arch Manning, Gunner Stockton, Marcel Reed, and John Mateer. The 2026 season for these guys is going to be absolutely wild, watching to see which of these future stars truly emerges. Which picks are going to shine brightest? It's all on the line.

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.