Jared Goff is NFL's Most Underrated QB, But Everyone's Asking If Justin Herbert Is OVERRATED

Alright, 12s, buckle up because the NFL hot takes are flying faster than a Jaxon Smith-Njigba deep ball! We're barely into the season, and already the biggest debate isn't about *our* Hawks, but who's getting the real love in the league. Everyone's talking about Jared Goff finally getting his due as the league's most underrated quarterback. But get this: at the same time, folks are seriously asking if Justin Herbert, Mr. Hype himself, might actually be... overrated?

The QB Takes Are Flying Wild

Can you believe it? The league is finally waking up to Jared Goff, with chatter saying he's the NFL's most underrated QB. It's about time, right? This dude consistently gets it done. But then you swing over to the other side of the coin, and it's a wild ride. Justin Herbert, the guy everyone's been hyping for years, is actually the subject of a huge debate. People are openly wondering if he's overrated. Crazy, because right alongside that question, you've got analysts saying he's a player to "buy stock in for '26," set to surge this season! They even listed him as one of six players ready to pop. How can both things be true at the same time? It's making my head spin.

Big Moves and Tough News Around the League

Beyond the QB debates, there's a bunch of other league stuff making waves right now. Big news out of Chicago, or should I say, Indiana: the Bears' board of directors actually voted to push forward with a stadium project in Indiana. Wild move. Over in Tampa, Baker Mayfield is already playing hardball, setting a camp deadline for contract talks. The word is, the sides are "not anywhere close," which is never good to hear early on. Then there's the truly tough stuff, with Broncos star Cooper jailed in Colorado on domestic violence charges. And a heartfelt moment out of Nashville, Titans receiver Robinson is wearing No. 4 this season to honor his late friend, Rondale Moore. It's a reminder that there's always more to the game than just the stats.

Roster Battles and Player Shifts

As teams finalize their rosters, we're also seeing some key position battles heating up. The Cowboys have their '24 first-round pick, Guyton, battling it out with a seventh-rounder, Thomas, for that starting left tackle spot. Talk about an open competition! And then there's the biggest player movement news: Myles Garrett, one of the most dominant defenders in the game, is now officially a Ram. Everyone's already breaking down how he'll fit into that Rams defense, with 2026 stat projections flying around. Plus, it's a constant reminder that only two top-10 first-round picks from the draft remain unsigned. Seven teams are also getting praise for having already addressed glaring weaknesses this offseason. It feels like everyone's making moves, trying to set themselves up for a big year. So, while we're all watching our Seahawks, hoping for a strong start under Coach Macdonald and seeing Sam Darnold sling it, it's clear the rest of the league is buzzing with drama, big takes, and surprising moves. The debates around guys like Goff and Herbert, the off-field news, and these massive player shifts like Garrett to the Rams, it all sets the stage for what's going to be a wild season. We, the 12s, know how quickly things can change. So grab another pint, because this NFL season, with all its twists and turns already, is just getting started. What crazy storyline will pop up next?

This article was created with AI assistance and reviewed by Seattle On Tap editorial staff. Always verify information with official team sources.